When a company experiences a cyber security incident, how it communicates with customers can be just as important as how it responds to the technical aspects of the breach.
Two recent incidents involving Australian supermarket giants Coles and Woolworths provide a useful comparison of how stakeholder communications can either preserve customer confidence or create further frustration, uncertainty and reputational damage.
Both companies have faced cyber-related issues during November 2026. However, their approaches to communicating with affected customers have been noticeably different.
Coles has been praised for its proactive, timely and transparent communications, while Woolworths has faced significant criticism over delayed notifications, inconsistent messaging and a lack of clarity surrounding its ongoing digital gift card issues.
The incidents demonstrate an important lesson for organisations: customers do not necessarily expect a company to have all the answers immediately, but they do expect to be kept informed.
The GOOD: Coles demonstrates proactive incident communications
Following its initial disclosure to the Australian Securities Exchange (ASX) on Monday, 16 November 2026, Coles moved quickly to establish a structured communications strategy around its cyber security incident.
Within 24 hours, the supermarket group had begun directly notifying customers and providing information about the incident through a dedicated Coles Group Updates portal.
Rather than allowing speculation to develop, Coles took steps to explain what had happened, what systems and services were affected, and what customers needed to know.
Several aspects of its response stand out.
1. Rapid and direct customer outreach
Coles sent direct notifications to customers within 24 hours of its initial ASX disclosure.
Importantly, the communications clarified that investigations had not identified evidence that customer, team member or supplier data had been compromised.
This provided customers with timely reassurance rather than leaving them to rely on media reports or speculation.
2. A dedicated information hub
Coles established a centralised incident updates page, including dedicated frequently asked questions for customers and suppliers.
Having a single, authoritative information source helps prevent inconsistent messaging and gives stakeholders somewhere to check for updates as an investigation progresses.
3. Clear operational reassurance
Coles addressed the practical concerns customers were likely to have.
Its communications confirmed that physical stores, online ordering, gift cards, Coles Plus subscriptions and Flybuys accounts remained safe and operational.
This is an important consideration during incident communications. Customers want to know not only whether their information is at risk, but whether they can continue using the services they depend on.
4. Proactive warnings about scams
Coles also warned customers to be alert to unexpected emails, text messages and phone calls requesting personal information.
This is particularly important following a publicly disclosed cyber incident, as threat actors frequently exploit customer uncertainty through impersonation and phishing campaigns.
By warning customers early, Coles helped reduce the opportunity for criminals to exploit the incident through secondary scams.
5. Early coordination with security agencies
Coles’ engagement with the Australian Cyber Security Centre (ACSC), alongside specialist security providers, demonstrated a structured approach to incident management.
Cyber security experts, including Kash Sharma from BlueVoyant, have highlighted how Australian organisations have learned from previous major incidents, including Optus and Medibank, that early transparency is important for maintaining public trust.
Coles also acknowledged minor disruptions to Liquorland click-and-collect services through its updates portal rather than allowing customers to speculate about wider operational problems.
Overall, Coles demonstrated that effective incident communications do not require every technical detail to be known. They require organisations to communicate what they know, acknowledge what they do not know, and provide regular updates.
The BAD: Woolworths’ confusing communications frustrate customers
In contrast, Woolworths has faced considerable criticism over its handling of an ongoing incident involving Australian customers’ digital WISH eGift cards.
Customers have reported hundreds of dollars being drained from their gift card balances, with some discovering the problem only when attempting to pay for purchases at the checkout.
Although Woolworths has begun replacing affected gift card balances, the company’s communications have attracted criticism from customers and security commentators.
The key concerns include:
1. Initial radio silence
Some customers reportedly received no proactive notification when their gift card balances were affected.
Instead, they discovered their cards had been emptied when attempting to use them at checkout.
A simple, timely notification could have prevented customers from being caught off guard and helped them understand that the issue was being investigated.
2. Gift cards disappearing without explanation
Customers have reported digital gift cards disappearing from their Everyday Rewards wallets without an accompanying explanation.
While cards may have been deactivated as part of the replacement process, failing to explain this action leaves customers wondering whether their accounts have been compromised or whether their money has been permanently lost.
3. Fragmented and inconsistent notifications
Customers have reportedly received different communications depending on how they interacted with Woolworths support.
Some received automated emails about replacement cards before submitting complaints, while others only received information through Woolworths’ in-app AI chatbot, Mandy, after actively chasing support.
This fragmented approach creates confusion and makes it difficult for customers to establish what is happening with their money.
4. Lack of transparency
Woolworths has faced criticism for not providing clear information about the underlying cause, the total number of affected customers or whether personal information may have been exposed.
Some customer support interactions have reportedly described the issue as an IT malfunction rather than a security incident.
Even where an investigation is ongoing and the root cause is unknown, organisations should communicate that fact clearly.
There is a significant difference between saying an investigation is continuing and providing no meaningful information at all.
5. Uninformed staff and broken customer support processes
Customers attempting to check gift card balances online have reportedly encountered error messages.
There have also been reports of in-store employees being unaware of the issue.
This creates another layer of frustration: customers are unable to obtain reliable information through the very channels they would normally expect to provide assistance.
The Woolworths incident currently concerns Australian Everyday Rewards / Everyday Gifting WISH cards. It is not currently identified as affecting New Zealand operations, although New Zealand customers should remain alert to phishing and supermarket impersonation scams.
What organisations should learn from these two incidents
The difference between Coles and Woolworths highlights several important principles that organisations should incorporate into their cyber incident response plans.
| Good stakeholder communications | Poor stakeholder communications |
|---|---|
| Notify affected customers promptly | Wait for customers to discover problems themselves |
| Establish a central incident updates page | Distribute fragmented and inconsistent information |
| Clearly explain what is known | Leave customers guessing about what has happened |
| Acknowledge what remains under investigation | Avoid answering reasonable questions |
| Explain which services and information are affected | Leave customers uncertain about operational impacts |
| Provide practical advice and scam warnings | Ignore the potential for secondary phishing attacks |
| Ensure frontline employees are briefed | Leave customer-facing staff uninformed |
| Provide regular updates, even when there is no significant change | Go silent until customers complain |
Five recommendations for organisations experiencing a cyber incident
- Communicate early: Do not wait until the investigation is complete before notifying affected stakeholders. Provide an initial notification explaining what is known and what is being investigated.
- Establish a single source of truth: Create a dedicated incident updates page that customers, employees, suppliers and other stakeholders can refer to. Keep it updated throughout the incident.
- Be transparent about uncertainty: If the root cause, scope or data exposure is unknown, say so. Avoid making assurances that cannot yet be supported by the investigation.
- Prepare customer-facing teams: Ensure contact centres, frontline employees and support staff receive consistent briefing material and know where to direct customers.
- Anticipate secondary attacks: Warn customers about phishing, fraudulent phone calls, fake support channels and other scams that may exploit the incident.
Final thoughts: Communication is part of incident response
Cyber security incident response is often measured by how quickly an organisation detects an intrusion, contains the threat, restores services and determines whether information has been compromised.
However, the Coles and Woolworths incidents demonstrate that stakeholder communications are another critical part of the response.
Coles showed that an organisation can communicate effectively without having every technical answer immediately available. It provided timely reassurance, established a central information source and warned customers about potential scams.
Woolworths, meanwhile, demonstrates how inconsistent notifications, a lack of proactive outreach and limited transparency can turn an already frustrating customer experience into a wider reputational problem.
The biggest lesson for organisations is simple: silence creates uncertainty, inconsistent messaging creates distrust, and poor communication can compound the damage caused by the original cyber incident.
A well-managed cyber incident response plan should therefore treat stakeholder communications as a core incident response capability, not an afterthought delegated to the public relations team.